I stayed up way too late last night finishing Dishonored. Or should I say Deushonored Ex? No, because that’s not the name of the game, but my point is that it’s very reminiscent of Deus Ex (and indeed it shared a designer).
One similarity is that the basic plot point is that you’re a security specialist who spectacularly fails at his job.
You play Corvo, Lord Protector to the above Empress for less than five minutes. (By the way, kudos to the designers for the Empress’s stylish pants. Gowns with big bustles would be more Victorian, but good conworlding should avoid slavish imitation.) Adam Jensen’s boss was awfully forgiving of his big screwup, but the new Lord Regent is not; you’re not only fired, but framed for the murder. Perhaps you could say you’re dishonored? Nah, framed is better.
Anyway, it turns out you have allies, the Loyalists, who hang out in a pub and send you on missions. Like, oh, say, Deus Ex, you can execute these either by stealth, sneaking up behind people and choking them into unconciousness, or you can just shoot and/or stab them. Oh, and like some other games, Deus Ex for example, you get some magical powers to help you stun and/or kill dudes.
What would stealth games be without this mechanic of poor peripheral vision and quick, safe comas? It’s a pity you can’t do this in real life.
Anyway, if you go for stealth at all you’ll be spending a lot of time creating artistic piles of bodies, like this:
As with, say, Deus Ex, there’s basically only one way to put people into comas– sneak up from behind. (Well, as in, say, Deus Ex, there’s also a sleep gun with limited rounds.) However, there’s a lot more options for getting around, and that makes it a better experience overall. The skills are disappointingly skewed toward combat, but I relied heavily on Dark Vision, Blink,and Possession. The first of these is basically Detective Vision, but the other two are novel and fun. Blink gives you a short teleport, which opens up all sorts of ways to traverse the maps, including vertically. It’s kind of like a non-athletic parkour.
Possession is the most fun: at level one you can temporarily take control of a rat or fish, which can be used to get past enemies or take unusual routes; at level two you can possess humans. This is very useful for getting past electrical barriers, for getting a victim into a quiet location to choke him, or even for evading combat. If anything it’s overpowered… in the later missions I was just a possessin’ fool.
There’s a Stop Time function that seems like it could be a good time, but I ended up barely using it. It’s most useful if you’re facing a bunch of alarmed enemies, but if you are, your stealth has already gone awry and it’s frankly easier to reload a quicksave.
I’m a bit spoiled by Arkham Asylum/City, where messing up stealth can almost always be taken care of by disappearing into the heights. In Deus Ex I got pretty tired of the cycle of quicksave, inch forward and alarm every enemy in town, reload. Dishonored is a little better thanks to Blink and Possession, which can be used to get out of trouble.
I didn’t do much combat, because it turns out that Dishonored has an annoying morality system. Nonlethal takedowns are Good; killing people is Bad. If you’re Bad, you not only get a darker ending (the plague never ends), but more enemies, plus some characters will give you a severe talking-to. I’m not much of a carnage guy, but still I find this sanctimonious nonsense. You even get Bad points for killing the zombie-like plague victims, and for killing the guy who actually murdered the Empress. Game designers, if you disapprove of a certain set of player actions, maybe don’t write a game about them. It’s just not that hard to do: just don’t give ’em a gun and sword.
No matter how careful you are, Corvo will screw up again, because a) he’s never read this post on the game designer’s almost inevitable plot mechanism, and b) he’s gauche enough to drink when he’s being toasted.
The game has a nice style of its own… well, not far from the Wonder City parts of Arkham City, but I’d much rather see more games that are vaguely Victorian instead of mediocrely medieval. Plus, as mentioned, the world here is just different enough to be interesting. There’s a lot of lore scattered about, and it’s a plus that it’s all in digestible-sized pieces. (It’s nice that the Elder Scrolls games have entire short stories in them, but I’m not always in the mood to read them.)
Even though each level is fairly constrained, they do a good job suggesting a much larger city. There are some nice cityscapes, all prettily 3-D-modelled. (Steam is actually behind on this– Steam games have very clever level design, but don’t have the enormous vistas of Dishonored or Skyrim or GTA or Saints Row.)
I’d say the level design is pretty good, in that I was only completely baffled twice, and I baffle easily. (My only cavil is on the very last map, where you’re on a lighthouse, and every video game instinct ever says that you should go up to the very tippy-top. I did, and there was nothing there… my target was a few floors below. Oh well. I think the top is used in the Bad ending.)
The setting, Dunwall, is a mixture of steampunk, fascism, and zombie apocalypse. The city is in the throes of a rat-borne plague, you see, which is said to have killed off a third of the population already. I read an interview that mentions that this was actually a serendipitous idea to explain the sparsely populated streets– plus, they came up with interesting things to do with the omnipresent rats.
The fascism bit bugs me a little, just because I don’t really like the fantasy trope that a government can turn Eeevil, or be redeemed, based on the personality at the top. Yes, I know, Hitler, but the whole problem with Germany was that it had very shallow experience with democracy. What does it say about Corvo and his Empress that they were an assassination away from being a police state in a death spiral? All the instruments of repression– the rapacious aristocrats, the oppressive response to the plague, the tallboys and electrical barriers, the Orwellian loudspeakers, the torture chamber– had to have been developed and deployed under the Empress’s rule.
As for replayability, I dunno. I might do another playthrough now that I know how it all goes, though all the plot elements (cutscenes, conversations, lore books) are a bit tedious to go through twice. It looks like I got through it in 23 hours, which is nothing for a Bethesda game (I’ve got 111 hours in Skyrim and I never even finished), and pretty light for a $60 game… but that’s OK as I got it for half off.
Anyway, even if I’m not quite as rapturous about it as some of my friends, it’s a good game, especially if you like stealth.